When selecting a dog food brand, recall history can be a key indicator of quality control and safety.
Below is a comparison of Life’s Abundance and other top-selling brands, including Purina, Blue Buffalo, Hill’s Science Diet, Iams, Royal Canin, and Diamond Pet Foods, based on their recall history and product safety concerns.
1. Life’s Abundance
0 Recalls – Life’s Abundance has never had a recall, demonstrating strict quality control.
 Safety – Small-batch production ensures safety and consistency.
No Artificial Additives – Free from artificial preservatives, colors, or fillers.
2. Purina
Multiple Recalls – Has experienced recalls due to salmonella, excess vitamin D, and foreign material contamination.
Past Issues Include:
• 2023 Recall – Due to potentially elevated vitamin D levels.
• 2013 Recall – Possible salmonella contamination.
Mass-Produced – Large-scale manufacturing increases quality control risks.
3. Blue Buffalo
Multiple Recalls – Several recalls for salmonella, mold, and mislabeling issues.
Past Issues Include:
• 2017 Recall – Possible aluminum contamination.
• 2015 Recall – High levels of beef thyroid hormone causing illness in dogs.
Marketing vs. Reality – Advertised as natural but has had ingredient concerns.
4. Hill’s Science Diet
Significant Recalls – Most notably for excessive vitamin D levels in 2019.
Past Issues Include:
• 2019 Recall – High vitamin D content, leading to kidney issues in dogs.
Prescription Diet Risks – Even veterinary-formulated diets have faced recalls.
5. Iams
Multiple Recalls – Has had recalls due to salmonella contamination and mold.
Past Issues Include:
• 2013 Recall – Possible salmonella contamination.
• 2011 Recall – Aflatoxin mold contamination affecting dog and cat food.
Owned by Mars Petcare – Part of a massive company that has had recalls across its pet food brands.
6. Royal Canin
Several Recalls – Has had recalls due to vitamin overdoses and melamine contamination.
Past Issues Include:
• 2007 Recall – Melamine contamination, linked to pet illnesses and deaths.
• 2006 Recall – Excess vitamin D causing serious health problems in pets.
Premium Price, Recall History – Despite its veterinary formulations, Royal Canin has faced safety concerns.
7. Diamond Pet Foods
Significant Recalls – One of the most recalled brands due to multiple contamination issues.
Past Issues Include:
• 2012 Recall – Massive recall due to widespread salmonella outbreak.
• 2005 Recall – Aflatoxin contamination linked to pet deaths.
Produces Many Other Brands – Also manufactures dog food for other companies, meaning recalls can affect multiple brands.
Final Comparison Chart
| Brand | Recalls | Common Issues | Key Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|
| Life’s Abundance | 0 Recalls | No major issues | Small-batch, high-quality |
| Purina | Multiple | Salmonella, excess vitamin D, foreign materials | Mass production increases risk |
| Blue Buffalo | Multiple | Contamination, mislabeling, thyroid hormone | Marketing doesn’t match reality |
| Hill’s Science Diet | Several | Excess vitamin D, prescription diet issues | Even vet diets can have recalls |
| Iams | Multiple | Salmonella, mold contamination | Part of a company with recall history |
| Royal Canin | Several | Melamine contamination, excess vitamin D | Premium price but recall concerns |
| Diamond Pet Foods | Multiple | Salmonella, aflatoxin, widespread issues | One of the most recalled brands |
Key Takeaways
• Life’s Abundance remains recall-free, making it one of the safest choices for pet owners.
• Many well-known brands have had multiple recalls, some linked to severe pet health risks.
• Always check recall history before choosing a pet food brand, as past recalls may indicate future risks.
• Ingredient sourcing and production methods matter – small-batch production can help reduce contamination risks.
By staying informed, pet owners can make the best decision for their furry friends’ long-term health.
Order Life’s Abundance
Need help selecting the right product for your puppy? Contact us – we’re here to help you every step of the way!
Shop With Confidence
When you shop with The Modern Pet USA, you’re not just buying a product—you’re investing in the health and happiness of your pet while supporting local and small businesses. Every item in our collection is carefully curated to ensure it meets the highest standards.
Explore our collection of apparel, birthday supplies, and more to see why so many pet parents trust us to provide the very best.
This post may contain links to products/services. If you make a purchase we may receive a commission at no added cost to you.
